Why Is Pumpkin Pie Considered An American Dessert

The History of Pumpkin Pie

In the United States, it’s difficult to picture a Thanksgiving dinner without the famous orange-crusted custard, which is created from strained, spiced, and twice-cooked butternut squash. The origins of pumpkins, which were initially cultivated in Central America around 5,500 B.C. and were one of the first foods brought back to Europe by the first European explorers from the New World, are one of the most fascinating aspects of our nation’s cultural heritage. The earliest recorded mention of orange gourds in Europe was in 1536, and within a few decades, they were being cultivated on a regular basis in England, where they were known as “pumpions,” from the French “pompon,” which was a reference to their rounder shape.

When the Pilgrims set sail for America on the Mayflower in 1620, it’s probable that some of them were as familiar with pumpkins as the Wampanoag, who assisted them in surviving their first year in Plymouth Colony by providing them with food.

Even though orange squash were quite useful (particularly as a technique to create bread without using a lot of wheat), they weren’t always well-liked.

Pumpkin pie was available in a variety of forms at the time, just a handful of which are still known to us today as traditional pumpkin pie.

  • In her 1670 “Gentlewoman’s Companion,” English writer Hannah Woolley recommended a pie made with alternating layers of pumpkin and apple, seasoned rosemary, sweet marjoram, and a pinch of thyme, among other ingredients.
  • Pumpkin pie had gained a place at the Thanksgiving table by the early 18th century as the event evolved into an important New England regional celebration.
  • Amelia Simmons’ groundbreaking 1796 book “American Cookery” included a pair of pumpkin pie recipes, one of which was quite close to the custard variation that is popular today.
  • Many of the most ardent abolitionists were from New England, and their favorite dessert was quickly mentioned in books, poetry, and broadsides as a result of their influence.
  • It’s no surprise that when Abraham Lincoln declared Thanksgiving a national holiday in 1863, observers in the Confederacy interpreted the action as an attempt to impose Yankee traditions on the Southerners.
  • After the Civil War, Thanksgiving—and, with it, pumpkin pie—began to spread across the country, thanks to articles in women’s magazines such as the one Hale published, which included pumpkin pie recipes.

The next time you open a can, take a moment to think about the people who came before you: industrialists, editors, housewives, anti-slavery crusaders, culinary experimenters, and Mesoamerican agriculturalists, all of whom contributed to the creation of your pumpkin pie.

Pumpkin pie – Wikipedia

Pumpkin pie

Type Pie
Course Dessert
Place of origin Canada,United States,United Kingdom
Main ingredients Pie shell,pumpkin,eggs,condensed milk,sugar,nutmeg,cinnamon,cloves,ginger

In addition to the pumpkin pie itself, various species of squash are also typically used in the filling of the pie, which is spiced and based on pumpkin. The pumpkin is a traditional emblem of harvest time, and pumpkin pie is traditionally served throughout the fall and early winter seasons. When pumpkin is in season in the United States and Canada, this dish is traditionally cooked for Thanksgiving and other special occasions. A single pie shell is used to bake the pie filling, which can range in color from orange to brown.

In general, the pie is flavored with cinnamon, powdered sugar, nutmeg, and cloves, among other things.

Cardamom and vanilla are also occasionally used as batter spices in baking.

The pie is frequently made using canned pumpkin or packaged pumpkin pie filling (which may or may not contain spices), which is mostly manufactured from types of Cucurbita moschata.


Making pumpkin pie filling is currently underway. Pie pumpkins, which are around 15 to 20 centimetres (6 to 8 inches) in diameter, are used in the preparation of pumpkin pies. They are far smaller than traditional jack o’lanterns. The first step in removing the edible portion of the pumpkin from its shell is to cut it in half and remove the seeds from inside. The two pieces are roasted until soft in a variety of ways, including an oven, an open fire, a stove top, or a microwave oven. Instead of cooking the pumpkin halves, they are sometimes brined to soften the pulp before serving.

Afterward, the pulp is combined with eggs, evaporated and/or sweetened condensed milk, sugar, and a spice blend known as pumpkin pie spice, which contains nutmeg and other spices (e.g., ginger, cinnamon), and then baked in a pie shell until golden brown.


a pumpkin pie that has only been partially devoured The pumpkin is indigenous to North America and is grown as a vegetable. The pumpkin was first sent to France, and it was from there that it was brought to Tudor England, where the flesh of the “pompion” was soon accepted as a pie filling substitute. It was possible to get pumpkin pie recipes in English cookbooks throughout the seventeenth century. One such cookbook was Hannah Woolley’s The Gentlewoman’s Companion (1675). Early American colonists were more likely to make a savory soup and serve it in a pumpkin than they were to make a sweet custard and serve it in a crust for their pumpkin “pies.” However, it wasn’t until the early nineteenth century that the recipes for pumpkin pie started appearing in Canadian and American cookbooks, and that pumpkin pie became a standard part of the Thanksgiving dinner menu.

According to tradition, the English pumpkin pie was made by filling the pumpkin with apples, spices and sugar before placing it in the oven as a whole pie.

Instead, many southern cooks prepared sweet potato pie, or flavored it with whiskey and pecans to give it a distinctively southern flavor.

Additional pumpkin pie-flavored products include candy, cheesecake, coffee, ice cream, french toast and pancakes; many breweries also produce a seasonal pumpkin ale or beer that is not flavored with pumpkins, but rather with pumpkin pie spices; and many restaurants and bakeries offer pumpkin pie-flavored dishes during the holiday season.

(Libby Select utilizes the C. moschata cultivar, Select Dickinson Pumpkin, for their canned pumpkins.) Pumpkin pies were barred from Thanksgiving feasts in 1947 as part of a rationing effort, mostly due to the eggs used in the dish, which was a result of World War II rationing.

In popular culture

I’m having a slice of homemade pumpkin pie.


  • Poem by Lydia Maria Child on Thanksgiving “In one of its lyrics, “Over the River and Through the Wood” (1844) makes reference to pumpkin pie: “Hurrah for the pleasure! “Is the pudding finished? / Hooray for the pumpkin pie!” wrote John Greenleaf Whittier in his poem “The Pumpkin” (The Pumpkin) “In the year 1850, the following happened:

Ah, on Thanksgiving Day, when pilgrims and guests arrive from the East and the West, from the North and from the South; When the gray-haired New Englander looks around his board, he is impressed. The old, shattered affectional ties have been repaired. In his search for his mother, the careworn man finds her, and the worn matron grins in the same spot where the girl had smiled earlier; What moistens the lips and brightens the eyes, what evokes memories of the past, such as the luscious Pumpkin Pie, are you looking for?


  • Oscar Ferdinand Telgmann and George Frederick Cameron penned the song “Farewell, O Fragrant Pumpkin Pie” for the operaLeo, the Royal Cadet(1889), which was performed by the following performers:

I bid you farewell, o heavenly pumpkin pie! We bid you farewell, dyspeptic pork! I do, however, intend to return to the college halls. Whatever happens on the battlefield, my newest sob and my latest sigh will be directed at you! And you, O doughnut, who art precious and rich, and whose frying is wonderfully brown! While I pitch my tent near the river that runs through Kingston town, thy shape will occupy a splendid place in memory’s chamber, and I will remember thee. And my Love—my darling Nell, the apple of my eye, how can I say goodbye to the girl who is the apple of my eye?

  • When a man returns home to his family’s home in Pennsylvania, he mentions homemade pumpkin pie in the song
  • The song “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” contains the line “Later we’ll have some pumpkin pie/And we’ll go caroling”
  • And the song ” Sleigh Ride “, which is also about sitting around a fire after being out in the snow and eating pumpkin pie, also mentions pumpkin pie.


The New Bremen Pumpkinfest, which took place in New Bremen, Ohio, featured the creation of the world’s biggest pumpkin pie. It was first used on September 25, 2010 and last modified on September 25, 2010. There were 550 kilograms (1,212 pounds) of canned pumpkin, 410 litres (109 US gallons) of evaporated milk, 2,796 eggs, 3.2 kilograms (7 lb) of salt, 6.6 kilograms (14 +1 2lb) of cinnamon, and 238 kilograms (525 lb) of sugar in the pie’s composition. The completed pie weighed 1,678 kg (3,699 lb) and had a circumference of 6 m (20 ft), making it the heaviest ever made.

See also

  • Bundevara
  • Pies on a list
  • A list of recipes for squash and pumpkin
  • Pie made with sweet potatoes
  • Pia colada
  • Key Lime Pie Tarte au custard
  • Dulce de leche
  • Dulce de leche


  1. Bombauer, I. S., and M.R. Becker’s article on the topic 1980. The Pleasures of Cooking New York City’s Bobs-Merrill Company publishes a recipe for “How to Make Homemade Pumpkin Pie.” PickYourOwn.org. Retrieved on October 31, 2011
  2. AbcAndrew F. Smith, “Pumpkins,” The Oxford Encyclopedia of Food and Drink in America
  3. AbcAndrew F. Smith, “Pumpkins,” The Oxford Encyclopedia of Food and Drink in America Gordon Campbell is the editor. The Oxford University Press published this book in 2003. Saint Mary’s College of California is a private liberal arts institution. The 21st of December, 2011
  4. Woolley, Hannah, The Gentlewoman’s Companion, 3rd ed. (London, England: Edward Thomas, 1682), “Pumpion Pye,” pages. 220–221
  5. “American Classic IX: Pumpkin Pie,” pp. 220–221
  6. “Pumpion Pye,” pp. 220–221
  7. “Pumpion Pye,” pp. 220–221 Delicious Food
  8. Traill, C.P., et al (1855). Settlers in Canada: A Guide for Newcomers The Old Countryman Office, p. 128. Toronto, Ontario: The Old Countryman Office. retrieved on 1st of August, 2019
  9. Kate Colquhoun is the author of this work (December 24, 2007). “A Dessert with a Story to Tell.” The New York Times is a newspaper published in New York City. Obtainable on December 4, 2010
  10. Reports on the herbaceous plants and quadrupeds of Massachusetts, 1840
  11. “How did the squash obtain its name?” (How did the squash get its name?) Library of Congress. abAriel Knoebel, retrieved on September 15, 2013
  12. Ab (November 21, 2017). “How Pumpkin Pie sparked a 19th-Century Culture War” is the title of the article. Atlas Obscura is a website dedicated to the exploration of the unknown. November 22, 2017
  13. Retrieved November 22, 2017
  14. R. W. Richardson’s “Squash and Pumpkin” is a classic (PDF). The National Plant Germplasm System is a project of the United States Department of Agriculture’s Agricultural Research Service. On September 24, 2015, a PDF version of this document was made available for download. Stephens, James M. “Pumpkin — Cucurbita spp.” Cucurbita spp. (Cucurbitaceae). Retrieved November 23, 2014. UofF stands for the University of Florida. On November 23, 2014, I was able to get a hold of
  15. Baggett, J. R., “Attempts to CrossCucurbita moschata(Duch.) Poir. ‘Butternut’ andC. pepoL. ‘Delicata’ “, Journal of Agricultural with Biological Research, vol. North Carolina State University is a public research university in Raleigh, North Carolina. On September 6, 2006, the original version of this article was archived. On November 23, 2014, I was able to get a hold of
  16. Michele Humes is a writer and editor (November 23, 2009). “The Way We Ate: The Year Harry Truman Passed on Pumpkin Pie” is a documentary about the year Harry Truman passed on pumpkin pie. Journal of a Diner. The New York Times is a newspaper published in New York City. retrieved on November 17, 2017
  17. Retrieved on November 17, 2017
  18. “The Pumpkin- Poets.org – Poetry, Poems, BiosMore” is a website dedicated to poets. Poets.org. The original version of this article was published on November 28, 2010. “Leo, the Royal cadet: Cameron, George Frederick, 1854-1885: Free DownloadStreaming: Internet Archive,” which was retrieved on August 19, 2010, had another title. Kingston, Ontario? : s.n., March 10, 2001
  19. [Kingston, Ontario? On August 19, 2010, ABC News reported that “2010 World Record Pumpkin Pie” had been set. Pumpkin Nook is a place where pumpkins grow. Obtainable on January 5, 2011

A Brief History of Pumpkin Pie in America

Allison Kelly, a scientific librarian who also happens to be a culinary specialist, has authored today’s blog. She has contributed her knowledge to a number of Inside Adams blog pieces on food history and cuisine, including Early American Beer and Early Mixology Books, among others. ADRIAEN VAN DER DONCK, an early landowner and the first lawyer in New Netherland, offered a marvelously thorough description of the natural and cultural worlds of that Dutch colony and its surrounds in 1655 in A Description of New Netherland, which is now considered a classic work on the subject.

From Icones plantarum medico-oeconomico-technologicarum cum earum fructus ususque descriptione =Abbildungen aller medizinisch-ökonomisch-technische Gewächse mit der Beschreibung ihres Gebrauches und Nutzens =Abbildungen aller medizinisch-ökonomisch-technische Gewächse mit der Beschreibung ihres Gebrauches und Nutzen The 1804 Biodiversity Heritage Library (contributed by the Missouri Botanical Garden) contains a work by Ferdinand Bernhard Vietz.

In van der Donck’s statement, the “English” alluded to in his description were the English colonists in New England, where pumpkins were a mainstay of their diet.

New Englanders made pumpkin ale, tossed dry pumpkin into flips, and boiled pumpkin as a vegetarian dish e.However, it was their pumpkin pie that, over the course of several centuries, evolved into an edible ico PIE PLATES, from the T.W.Root’s Hardware Catalogue, published in 1890, available at: /lccn.loc.gov/unk820159.

  1. “.
  2. Because they are so sweet and dry, it is necessary to add water and vinegar to them before stewing them in the same way as apples are cooked.
  3. However, by 1796, when Amelia Simmons’ American Cookery was published, pumpkin pie had evolved into a recognizable form that we would recognize today.
  4. y.Amelia Simmons offered two recipes for “pompkin” puddin in her book American Cookery.
  5. s.
  6. American cooks have continued to use this fundamental style as a foundation.
  7. Mary Randolph, in The Virginia Housewife (1824), made a pumpkin pie that was similar to this one, but with the addition of “a wine glass of brandy” to taste.
  8. Cook a fine sweet pumpkin till soft and dry, then press it through a sieve to remove the pulp.

It should be somewhat dry if the mixture is too liquid; spread some paste around the borders and in the bottom of a shallow dish or plate; then pour in the mixture; cut some thin pieces of paste, twist them and arrange on top of the dish or plate; bake until it is well browned; A recipe for “pumpkin pudding” was included in Miss Leslie’s Seventy-five Receipts for Pastry, Cakes, and Sweetmeats(1827), written by Eliza Leslie, an American author of numerous popular 19th-century cookbooks, who included a recipe for “pumpkin pudding” in her cookbook.

  • This pudding is what we would today refer to as a one-crust or open-face pie, with the bottom lining made of “puff paste” rather of the “common paste” that she used for her double-crusted pie.
  • After only a few decades, pumpkin pie had become a cultural symbol and a must-have for every Thanksgiving dinner table.
  • s.
  • a:But here, beneath the glorious Freedom’s sky, in a nation that heroism has won, we’ll sing our renowned Pumpkin Pie, from the moment the sun rises till the moment it sets.
  • For children between the ages of four and six years ol 184.
  • 4.
  • In part because of its iconic position, pumpkin pie appears to have altered little over the next 100 years, as demonstrated by this recipe from an Iowa cookbook published in 1887.


Raws, for example.


Recipe calls for a quart of pumpkin, five quarts of heavy cream, four eggs, three cups of sugar, one scant teaspoon of ginger, and four teaspoons of cinnamon.

t.from The Grocer’s Encyclopedia, published in 1913.


Although it is occasionally used as a vegetable, its primary application is in the preparation of ‘pumpkin pies.’ However, despite a slew of trendy variations on the original—pumpkinchiffon pie, pineapple pumpkin pie, pineapple whoopee pies, pumpkin ice cream pie, and pumpkin Alaska pie—the essential pumpkin pie has remained true to its origins: mashed and cooked pumpkin, milk or cream (or both), eggs (or both), sugar (or both), and spices (or both).

  • However, practically everything about pumpkin pie has altered dramatically since Amelia Simmons’ recipes were first published more than a century ago.
  • 11 A large number of cooks were no longer willing or able to “stew pumpkin all day,” and they soon welcomed the canned product because of its convenience.
  • By the 1920s, canned pumpkin, along with canned cranberry sauce, had become a fixture of every grocer’s seasonal advertising, and was available year-round.
  • Kilburn) in 1904.
  • Kilburn) in 1904.
  • the situation of the pumpkin pie industry was discussed in detail in an essay written by W.
  • McClure for O hio Farmer in 1905 titled “Horticulture: The Pumpkin Pie Industry.” A considerable quantity of pumpkins are cultivated in northeastern Ohio for canning purposes.where one of the largest canneries for pumpkins on the American continent is located.

When canned, a ton of pumpkins will yield around 1200 pounds.

Beckert in 1902.

Gilbert Nursery and Seed Catalog Collection on the Internet is a collection of catalogs from the Henry G.

Commercially canned pumpkin was not only more convenient, but it was also typically safer than home-canned pumpkin, according to the National Pumpkin Board.

Lee, head of the National Canned Foods Week committee, in “To Live Well and Cheaply,” published in Grocer’s Magazine in 1913.

The canning of pumpkin is a massive undertaking that is far more complex than most people realize.

One packer had 4,000 tons of this exquisite fruit on his grounds at one point last season, which was an unique sigh of relief.

Many customers had the choice of picking from a variety of standardized commercially baked foods, including breads, cakes, and pies, during the opening years of the twentieth century, as industrialization introduced new milling and baking equipment, and, later, electrically driven machinery and ovens.

  1. Nineteenth-century city newspapers depict gigantic bakeries or “pie-factories” that produced thousands of pies for the supply of restaurants, hotels, boardinghouses, smaller bakeries, and individual family households.
  2. “The Pie and its Devotees: The Season for Pumpkin and Cranberry Pie is at Hand,” states a note in The New York Times on September 14, 1889, referring to the pumpkin and cranberry pie.
  3. The pumpkin pie season was still considered newsworthy in the twentieth century, according to some sources.
  4. The first Thanksgiving advertisements appeared in the early 1960s, and they included not just canned pumpkin pie mix and bakery pies, but also ready-to-serve frozen pie.” s.
  5. y.Bakers Review, published on October 19, 20Frozen pies were touted as “failure-proof” in food magazines and newspaper food sections.

“To dress up the pie, and as a homage to its New England ancestry, a coating of Pilgrim’s Whipped Ginger Toppin is applied at the end.” g.A frozen pumpkin pie that has been dressed up (pumpkin pie, skee) creative commons (ze CreativeCommons) A large number of people have continued to make their own pumpkin pie despite the widespread availability, popularity, and convenience of both frozen and bakery-bought pumpkin pies.

Many baby boomers grew up identifying pumpkin pie with the recipe on the back of the pumpkin can, the one with evaporated milk, eggs, canned pumpkin, a pre-baked crust—and pumpkin pie spice—while for some chefs in the late twentieth century, it meant stewing a pie pumpkin.

Highsmith), PrintsPhotographs, Library of Congress, https://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/201663218/ 1/By the middle of the twentieth century, pumpkin pie spice had become widely available.

According to legend, the spice mixture always contains some combination of ginger, nutmeg, mace, cloves, cinnamon or allspice–all of which are spices we may recognize as being commonly used in colonial American cookery, although they were presumably metered out more generously than they are now.

The USDA’s Agricultural Research Service has created a pumpkin pie. Image Galleries are available for purchase. ry

How Pumpkin Pie Became An American Staple

Photograph courtesy of Justin Sullivan/Getty Images It can be topped with whipped cream or dusted with streusel before baking. Every fall, you see it, and you probably consume more than half of your body weight in it around the time of Thanksgiving. Pumpkin pie has been a staple of both American desserts and leftovers for as long as anybody can remember. It is a favorite of children and adults alike. Pumpkin pie is one of the best fall desserts because it has a pudding-like filling that tastes like fresh pumpkins and toasty cinnamon, as well as a buttery, flaky crust that is baked to perfection.

  • As part of the Columbian Exchange, a native crop of North America was transported to Europe, where it has remained ever since.
  • Cooking delicacies such as French chef Francois Pierre la Varenne’s 17th century recipe for “Tourte de Pumpkin,” an almond-pumpkin dessert baked in a pastry crust, would be considered the early European “roots” of the modern-day pumpkin pie, according to the University of Portsmouth.
  • ) However, you are most likely interested in learning how pumpkin pie got so famous in the United States.
  • Who was the inventor of the first canned pumpkin?

From table to table: the history of pumpkin pie

Anna Pustynnikova/Shutterstock Amelia Simmons published “American Cookery” in 1796, making it the first cookbook published in the United States by an American. Simmons’ best-selling cookbook includes a recipe for “pompkin pudding,” which is a pumpkin custard cooked in a pastry crust. In 1824, Mary Randolph wrote “The Virginia House-wife,” which included a recipe for pumpkin pie as well as other household tips. While the recipes for Simmons’ and Randolph’s pumpkin pies differ in minor details, both recipes follow a basic formula for making a primitive pumpkin pie that is roughly contemporary in nature.

Not only did diners laud the dessert, but it was also commemorated in songs and poetry written throughout the 1800s in America, with one notable example being “Over the River and Through the Woods,” written by abolitionist and poet Lydia Maria Child, who was born into slavery (via thePoetry Foundation).

This eliminated the time-consuming task of prepping the raw pumpkin, which was one of the most difficult challenges to overcome while cooking pumpkin pie.

Today, pumpkin pie is preferred by 35% of individuals in the United States above pecan, apple, or sweet potato pie for Thanksgiving dinner (viaYouGov). After all, why wouldn’t they? It is, in fact, a long-standing American custom.

A Brief History Of Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie with pacman on it | courtesy of Daniel Catt/Wikimedia Commons Pumpkin pie is the iconic Thanksgiving dish in the United States. This yearly celebration would be incomplete without a piece of orange-tinged custard with a flaky crust, served on a table adorned with bowls of cranberry sauce, gravy, mashed potatoes, and a turkey. It is believed that pumpkins, originally known in England as “pumpions,” were named after the French word “pompon.” Pumpkins have a long history: they were among the first foods brought back from the New World by European explorers, and their origins can be traced back to 5500 BC, when they were first cultivated in Central America.

  • The earliest recorded mention of pumpkin in Europe goes back to 1536, with the return of European explorers from their abroad expeditions.
  • It’s no surprise that this spherical squash found its way into pastries so rapidly in a society where pie-making had been practiced for hundreds of years.
  • Later, the colonists and Wampanoag joined together for a three-day harvest festival; it is said that pumpkin, which could be quickly turned into bread without the need of flour or yeast, made it to the table.
  • The pumpkin pie recipe in a 1653 Frenchcookbook called for milk-boiled pumpkin that is drained and baked in a crust, while a 1670 recipe by Englishwriter Hannah Woolley called for a pie filled with layers of pumpkin and apple with rosemary, thyme, and marjoram on top of a crust.
  • The Whole Slice of Pumpkin Pie |
  • Pumpkins/Pexels |
  • Public Domain/WikiCommons |

Pumpkin pie did not become widely recognized as a national Thanksgiving tradition until the publication of Amelia Simmons’ cookbookAmerican Cookery (the first truly “American” cookbook) in 1796 – the book contained two recipes for pumpkin pie, one of which was very similar to the recipes widely used today.

As a result, it should come as no surprise that the pie may be found in early American books and poems because it was already popular among New England colonists.

However, this had no influence on the expansion of Thanksgiving (and pumpkin pie) throughout the United States.

Putting pumpkin pie on the Thanksgiving table got that much easier, ensuring its place as an all-American ritual for generations to come.

Pumpkin Pie History, Whats Cooking America

Pumpkin pie is a popular dessert in the United States and Canada, and with good reason. In other regions of the world, it is only sometimes available. It is very popular around the time of the Thanksgiving celebration. Every year during the Thanksgiving season, families gather around the table to share a meal and commemorate the occasion. The pumpkin pie, which is the traditional Thanksgiving dessert, has been grabbing the spotlight for hundreds of years. Pepon is the Greek term for “big melon,” and the name “pumpkin” comes from this word.

1621– Early American settlers at Plimoth Plantation (1620-1692), the first permanent European settlement in southern New England, may have made pumpkin pies (of a sort) by stewing pumpkins or by filling a hollowed-out pumpkin shell with milk, honey, and spices and baking it in hot ashes, according to historical records.

  • Native American tribes in the northeastern United States farmed squash and pumpkins.
  • Historians believe that the settlers were not particularly taken with the Indians’ squash and/or pumpkins until they were forced to endure their first difficult winter, during which almost half of the settlers died as a result of scurvy or exposure.
  • Approximately 50 years after the first Thanksgiving in America, this was the beginning of what would become pumpkin pie.
  • Currently, historians of Plimoth Plantation are unsure as to whether or not the colonists had access to any cookbooks during their time on the plantation.
  • The French Cook was translated and published in England in 1653 under the title The French Cook.
  • Bake it after you’ve placed it in your paste sheet.

recipes for a type of “pumpion pie” were beginning to emerge in English cookbooks as early as the sixteenth century, including theThe Queen-like closet, or opulent cabinet filled with all manner of unusual receipts for preserving, candying, and cooking written by Hannah Wooley and W.M.1670–The Queen-like Closetwritten by Hannah Wooley: The Compleat Cook – Expertly Prescribing the Most Ready Wayes, Whether Italian, Spanish, or French, for Dressing of Flesh and Fish, Ordering Of Sauces, or Making of Pastry To create a Pumpion-Pie, follow these steps: Pumpion should be pared and cut into thin slices, then dipped in beaten eggs and herbs, which should be finely chopped, and fried until done, then placed in a pie with butter, raisins, currants, sugar, and sack, with some sharp apples in the bottom, and baked until done, then brushed with butter and served in a pie plate.

Pumpion Pie – Take about halfe a pound of Pumpion and slice it, along with a handfull of Tyme, a little Rosemary, Parsley, and sweet Marjoram slipped off the stalks, and chop them smal, then take Cinamon, Nutmeg, Pepper, and six Cloves, and beat them; then mix them, and beat them together, and put in as much Sugar as you think fit; after it is fried, let it stand The first authentically American cookbook, American cooking, written by an orphan from the United States and published in 1796, was written by an orphan from the United States.

It was the first American cookbook to be written and published in the United States, as well as the first cookbook to include recipes for foods that were indigenous to the United States.

1.One quart stewed and strained pumpkin, 3 pints cream, 9 beaten eggs sugar, mace, nutmeg, and ginger, laid into paste No.

7 or 3, and with a dough spur, cross and chequer it, and baked in dishes for three quarters of an hour Pumpkin Pudding No. 2 (also known as Pumpkin Pudding No. 1). In a pie crust, combine one quart of milk, one pint of pumpkin, four eggs, molasses, allspice, and ginger; bake for one hour.

The Original Pumpkin Pie The Way The Pilgrims Made It

This dish has piqued my interest tremendously! When a concept comes to fruition, it gives me such a thrill! I hope you will give this recipe for The Original Pumpkin Pie – The Way the Pilgrims Made It a try and make it a new Thanksgiving tradition for you and your family. Despite the fact that pumpkin pie may have been served during the first Thanksgiving in America, it was not the pie that we know and love today. It would have been impossible to bake any kind of pie crust 393 years ago for the first Thanksgiving in Plymouth (Massachusetts) since there was no flour available.

  • The early English immigrants in North America improvised by hollowing out pumpkins, filling the shells with milk, honey, and spices to produce a custard, then roasting the pumpkins whole in hot ashes, according to some accounts of their experiences there.
  • The Original Pumpkin Pie – As Made by the Pilgrims was born, and I couldn’t have been happier with the outcome!
  • When you bite into this, it tastes just like crème brûlée; it’s delectable (which is why leaving the top to brown is such a good idea!
  • Whoop!

If you are looking for a dish to add to your Thanksgiving gathering this year, one with agreat story, history and a wow factor, why not try whipping my modern take on The Original Pumpkin Pie – The Way The Pilgrims Made It

A single serving of this would feed 4-5 people, so you could prepare a couple of these and arrange them along the center of your dessert table as a centerpiece.

If you enjoy vintage recipes like this or just want to make something that’s different and CRAZY DELICIOUS yet SO SO simple! Make this Nantucket Pie. I have been making it for half my life and one bite always gets newbies excited!

It’s a classic dish from New England (again, Pilgrim territory, to be exact, haha). This Pie isn’t even close to being a pie. I really like how it incorporates seasonal cranberries and walnuts. There are only six ingredients. I sincerely hope you like it as much as my family does! More Thanksgiving Dessert Ideas are available here. I’d like to wish you and your family a tasty and joyous Thanksgiving! XO – Colleen XO – Colleen

The Original Pumpkin Pie – The Way The Pilgrims Made It

Make pumpkin pie the way it was intended to be made by the first Americans: from scratch. In the center of the pumpkin is a custard filling. So unique for a holiday dessert, and it’s absolutely tasty. Preparation time: 15 minutes Cooking time: 1 hourTotal time: 1 hour and 15 minutes Dessert and Thanksgiving are on the menu. Cuisine:American Custard Pumpkin Pie, Original Pumpkin Pie, Pilgrims Pumpkin Pie are all examples of pumpkin pies. Servings:6servings Calories:402kcal

  • 1 small pumpkin (about) Sugar pumpkin is 4-5 inches in height and 12-15 inches in circumference
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 3 big eggs + 4 egg yolks
  • 1-1/2 cupsheavy cream
  • 1 teaspoon cornstarch
  • A pinch of salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon vanilla bean paste or vanilla essence
  • Preheat your oven to 350°F. Prepare your pumpkin by scooping out the seeds and pulp and placing it on a baking sheet
  • Do not lay the pumpkin’s top (stem) on the baking sheet yet
  • Preheat the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the sugar, eggs, and vanilla extract until well incorporated
  • Whisk in the heavy cream, cornstarch, and salt until the mixture is completely smooth. Pour the mixture into your prepared pumpkin (leaving approximately 3/4 inch of space between the filling and the top of the pumpkin) and bake it for 30 minutes at 350 degrees. Preheat the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit, uncovered. Remove the pumpkin from the oven after 15 minutes and cover the top loosely with aluminum foil (don’t let it come into contact with the top of the custard or it will stick and “ruin” the appearance) before baking for another 15 minutes
  • Reduce the oven temperature to 375 degrees Fahrenheit, set the top of the pumpkin on the baking sheet, and bake for another 15 minutes. After 30 minutes, remove the foil and bake for a further 30 minutes, or until a knife put into the center of the custard comes out largely clean. Allow for an hour of cooling time after removing the pumpkin from the oven, then place it in your cold garage (loosely wrapped with plastic wrap or aluminum foil) or your refrigerator and allow the custard to set for 6 to 8 hours or overnight. Pour custard onto small bowls when ready to serve (you may scrape the edges a little as you scoop it out if you wish to scrape off some of the cooked pumpkin for more taste, I am sure the Pilgrims didn’t waste anything)

Six servings|402 calories|27 grams of carbohydrates|4 grams of protein|31 grams of fat | 19 grams of saturated fat|2 grams of polyunsaturated fat|9 grams of monounsaturated fat|1 gram of trans fat|191 milligrams of cholesterol|62 milligrams of sodium|90 milligrams of potassium|25 grams of sugar|1285 international units of vitamin A|1 milligram of vitamin C|64 milligrams of calcium|1 milli

Reader Interactions

Without pumpkin pie, holidays in the United States aren’t nearly as soothing or joyous as they could be. (And, let’s be honest, where would Starbucks be if it didn’t provide pumpkin spice lattes?) However, consider the following: A pie is a pie, and pumpkin pie is a pie. Squash has been added. Who in the world came up with the idea of stuffing a pie with a squash?

In the narrative of how pumpkin pie got so famous, medieval traditions, indigenous foods from Africa and the Americas, and the most sought-after items from old trade routes via Asia and the Middle East are all thrown together in unexpected ways.

The Pie’s Past

In the mean time, lets start with something as simple as a slice of pie, which, according to Ken Albala, professor of history at the University of the Pacific in Stockton, California, was more popular in Europe throughout the Middle Ages than it is in the United States now. Aside from that, he’s the author of more than 25 books on food and food history, the most recent of which is “Food in Early Modern Europe.” There were a lot of pies and fruits, as well as meat and fish, and veggies, according to Albala in an email.

  1. Furthermore, the crusts were not consumed.
  2. Albala adds that medieval pies were produced freeform without the use of a pie dish, which resulted in their standing taller than what we are accustomed to seeing in pies today.
  3. Upon the arrival of European immigrants in North America, the use of pie crust became commonplace and a very significant component of daily life.
  4. By the 17th century, the traditional method of enjoying pie was to consume “a slice.”

Pumpkin Pie Filling

When it comes to the filling, there was no pumpkin available in Medieval Europe. As a substitute, Europeans fashioned pies with gourd contents, preferring African variations over those from other parts of the world. Because of theColumbian Interchange—the exchange of plants, food, animals, germs, people, and culture brought about by European journeys to North and Central America—Europeans were introduced to pumpkins for the first time during their travels across the region. Some foods from North, Central, and South America took years for them to accept (potatoes and tomatoes were deemed deadly), but pumpkins were accepted almost immediately since they were closely related to gourds but had a more flavorful flavor.

  1. Furthermore, what about the spice combination that we now identify with the season of fall, coziness, and lengthier lineups at coffee shops?
  2. During that time period, a similar spice mix was employed in just about everything.
  3. Sugar was also hard to get by.
  4. Until the 16th century, Albala claims that the cinnamon, clove, ginger, and nutmeg combination could be found everywhere.
  5. There are conventional and ‘poudre fort’ combinations that are hotter with pepper and grains of paradise, and sometimes a combination of the two.
  6. Take thinly sliced apples, sliced roundways, and stack them between two layers of froise, with a layer of apples and currants sandwiched between the layers.

If you have six yolks of eggs and some white wine or verjuyce, you may create a caudle out of it, but not too thick; then chop up the lid and put it in, and mix them well together till the eggs and pumpion are not discernible; then serve it.”

Colonists Claim Pumpkin Pie

Eventually, by the 18th century, the British had lost their fondness for pumpkin pie and had begun to link pumpkins with Native Americans in a bad light. Instead, they favored apple, pear, and quince pies, which they thought to be more refined in their presentation. However, around the same time, colonists in America began to experiment with their own versions of pumpkin pie. Amelia Simmons’ book “American Cookery” is often regarded as a form of “culinary Declaration of Independence” from the United Kingdom among food historians and chefs.

In Simmons’ pumpkin pie recipe, he says, you should use one quart of stewed and strained pumpkin, three pints of heavy cream, nine well-beaten eggs with sugar, mace, nutmeg, and ginger, laid into paste No.

Despite the fact that Simmons’ recipe is quite similar to what we now identify as conventional pumpkin pie, she does not include a top crust.

All You’ve Ever Wanted to Know (and More!) about the History of Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie is a traditional holiday dish in the United States. Even though we all like eating it, have any of us ever stopped to consider where it comes from? Who do we owe our gratitude to for this creation? With the recent introduction of “clear” pumpkin pie, I’ve been wondering about the origins of this dish and how it came to have a permanent spot on every Thanksgiving dinner table. So, without further ado, here is the whole history of pumpkin pie.

Early History

It wasn’t until many of the settlers at Plymouth Plantation grew ill or perished during their first winter in America that they began to think about the humble pumpkin as a possible food source. When the Native Americans gave them this fruit, they used it to make (kind of) pumpkin pies by stewing the pumpkin’s insides and then filling the hollowed-out pumpkin shells with milk, honey, and spices, which they then baked. Then they cooked it over a hot fire made of ashes. It is true that there were no pastry crusts available in the colonies during that time period!

  • (The True French Cook).
  • “Tourte of pumpkin – Boil it with excellent milk, pour it through a straining pan extremely thick, and combine it with sugar, butter, a pinch of salt, and, if you choose, a few pressed almonds; let everything be very thin,” it stated.
  • Afterwards, sprinkle it with sugar and put it on a serving tray.” By the 1670s, the “pumpion pie” had appeared in a number of European cookbooks, but not in any that were published in the United States.
  • This book contains hints and recommendations for the ordinary living of a 17th century woman, as well as historical information.
  • Woolley recommends preparing a tiered pie, with layers of pumpkin, apple, and herbs between the layers of pastry.
  • Simmons’ “pumpkin puddings” were the closest approach we’d come to the pumpkin pie filling we’re all familiar with and adore today.
  • She described a Thanksgiving table setting that included a variety of sweets, but noted that “the pumpkin pie filled the most prominent position.” another renowned poem titled “Thanksgiving Day,” written by abolitionist Lydia Maria Child in 1842, in which she conveyed her joy for the holiday.

The following lines eloquently described the sensation that I believe we can all connect to when we view that beautiful dessert: “Hurrah for the fun!/ Is it time to make the pudding? / Hurrah for the pumpkin-pie!”

Modern Pumpkin Pies

Canning products were the primary focus of Libby’s, the canned goods brand at the time (1929). Libby’s, on the other hand, began manufacturing canned pumpkin puree in 1929, allowing homes to create pumpkin pies more quickly and effectively. innovation! 2017—Alinea, a non-traditional, innovative restaurant in Chicago, created a pumpkin pie that was easy to see through. This pie, which was created by Chef Simon Davies utilizing molecular gastronomy methods, will confuse your head as well as your taste sensations.

So there you have it, a comprehensive history of pumpkin pies.

Season of pumpkin pie wishes to you!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *